Analysis of a Real Haunted House
Analysis of a Real Haunted House.
Everyone has his/her own theories and ideas about Haunted
Houses, and these claims are based on assumptions and clichés without
proofs. However, "real" haunted houses have always existed, as one
evidence from Paranormal Story Archives shows, and these houses hide something
unusual and mysterious, as "similar haunted houses" from such
literary works as "Haunting of Hill House" by Shirley Jackson,
"Tales of Horror" by Laura Mullen and "Halloween
Street" by Steve Rasnic Tem. The role of these houses, as described in
many other articles and essays, is not that simple.
In fact, the
existence of the haunted houses is closely connected with moral behaviour of
every society; it seems that these houses want to tell very important things to
human beings, to reveal secrets of universe and make people believe in
supernatural events, in the power of good and evil. All these issues have
occupied the public interest for centuries. Although the fascination has
changed today, it is still a topic that is a cause for great speculation.
Unfortunately, humans are not able to interpret the signs of these
haunted houses, because they are afraid of them, refusing to believe those who
experienced something unusual. People always prefer to close their eyes to the
most obvious and important matters, but facts are stubborn things, and persons
can't hide behind them. They can't deny the existence of such haunted houses,
as the house considered the "most haunted house in America"
(Paranormal Story Archives, p. 20). This was the home of carpetbagger Charles
Wright Congelier, his Mexican wife Lyda, and a young servant girl, Essie, and
the house was located at 1129 Ridge Avenue, in Manchester on the North Side of
data, this house is one of the brightest examples of haunted houses of the
past, and the most intriguing one. It attracted attention of many specialists,
like Dr. Brunichter and Thomas Edison, and such famous authors as Richard Winer
and Nancy Osborn gave their opinion of this house in their book Haunted
Houses. This article provides a very detailed observation of the house,
starting from the tragedy in the family of Charles Wright Congelier, when in
the winter of 1871 Lyda discovered Charles having an affair with the maid, she
fatally stabbed Charles and chopped off Essie's head. This cruelty was a
starting point in turning the house into a haunted one, and, in accordance with
various sources, every haunted house reveals a secret connected with murder.
Further, as story tells, the house was vacant for more than twenty years, as
people were afraid to occupy such horrible place. In 1892 the attempt to
accommodate railroad workers failed, as they were unable to live in the place
with the sobbing and screaming of a woman.
Of course, no
one could tell for sure, whether people really heard those strange noises. This
was the end of the 19th century, and humans possessed neither knowledge,
nor ability to check the house. Perhaps, the workers' claims were tales, but,
on the other hand, there is no smoke without a fire, and further events had
proved this proverb. Dr. Adolph C. Brunrichter was the next person who had
bought the house. However, a year later something strange happened there, and
when the police arrived, they found a decomposed female body strapped to the
bed and five headless young women in basement graves. As Winer and Osborn
think, Dr. Brunrichter had been experimenting with severed heads. The doctor
himself had disappeared and true reasons of the events were not clarified, the
only witness was the haunted house.
Strange, as it may seem, the house somehow wanted to remain vacant, and
the next awful event took a really tragic turn. One night two of the emigrant
Equitable Gas Company workers were found dead in the basement. As the story in
the Paranormal Story Archives tells, "one had a board driven like a stake
through his chest and the other was hanging from a rafter" (p.20). And the
strangest thing is that these men had both been seen alive a few minutes
earlier. Since that time many famous scientists had been interested in the
house, and in 1920 Thomas Edison came to study it. However, his death prevent
him from finishing the experiment, but Winer and Osborn wrote that Thomas
Edison's visit to the house at 1129 Ridge Avenue changed his attitude towards
afterlife. In fact, as many witnesses revealed, this haunted house was full of
sex orgies, demonic possession, torture and murder.
Thus, it was considered as the house of evil, and even its destruction
was really strange. On the morning of November 15, 1927 the nearby giant gas
storage tank owned by the Equitable Gas Company exploded with a force, which
was felt across the county. The force was so strong that people thought that
the earthquake had begun. According to Winer and Osborn, the haunted house was
the only structure destroyed in the blast, for which no trace was ever found.
"real" haunting house has some similarities with the houses described
by famous writers Shirley Jackson and Laura Mullen. First of all, all these
houses terrified people with strange and awful sounds, and made them crazy.
Outside they seemed ordinary buildings, but inside they were alive creatures
that were invisible to human eyes. The house of Charles Wright Congelier
revealed the sobbing and screaming of a woman. And the house in the story of
Laura Mullen "Tales of Horror" expressed voices and breath of
something: "Voices, voices, out of the walls And the ceiling's and floors.
And then nothing stays where you put it (Mullen, p. 11). And then
another proof: "There was the muted sound of sobbing and yet THERE WAS NO
ONE IN THAT ROOM!" (Mullen, p. 13). In the story of Shirley Jackson
strange things also happened in the house: sounds, pounding, and
Thus, in all three cases people heard some strange noises. Such
similarity is obvious, as these two literary works were based on real facts,
Mullen and Jackson analysed odd events in the haunted houses, making their own
conclusions. However, both of them thought that every haunted house covered
someone's crime, and ghosts sought justice. The works of these writers were
aimed to investigate one of the most intriguing paranormal phenomena of the
universe. Shirley Jackson decided to write a story about a haunted house after
reading about a group of nineteenth century "psychic researchers" who
studied a house and reported their supposedly scientific findings to the
Society for Psychic Research.
Although, the writer failed to discover something great in these reports,
she was really excited by the prospect of creating her own haunted house and
providing her own explanation of it. She even found out a California house,
which looked like a haunted house. In addition to all these attempts, she read
a lot of ghost stories, and, as a matter of fact, she believed in ghosts.
That's why her haunted house was so real.
Another similarity between a 'real' house and two fiction houses lays in
people's perceptions of normal and abnormal. They used to accept things as they
are, if they imagine a haunted house it must be dark, old and strange.
Otherwise, they won't believe in its existence. Thus, the haunted house
described by Shirley Jackson is just the same, as the real house of Charles
Wright Congelier and invented house of Mullen. Here, how Jackson describes it:
"Hill House, not sane, stood by itself against its hills, holding darkness
within; it had stood so for eighty years and might stand for eighty more.
Within, walls continued upright, bricks met neatly, floors were firm, and doors
were sensibly shut; silence lay steadily against the wood and stone of Hill
House, and whatever walked there, walked alone" (Jackson, p.1).
This description reveals the dark energies of the house and shows the
real protagonists of both literary works – the houses, which fulfil their role
as Bad Places, the horrific archetypes of any location with a powerful sense of
wrongness. With their dark descriptions Jackson and Mullen suggest rather than
explain, and frighten more by what they do not say about the houses rather than
what they do.
As a matter of fact, the haunted houses of Jackson and Mullen were based
on their discovery of the quiet evil that pervades ordinary life. Everything
around - the house, the person, the action - is never quite what they seem to
be. This is true in our modern life. This is the third similarity among three
houses. All of them revealed something hidden beneath, something that seemed
simple and, at the same time, different from peoples' ideas of universe. In
short, this is supernatural, human beings are unable to understand it, if they
don't make an effort to accept all components of a 'haunted house', they will
be trapped in their own prejudices. There are plenty of clues, but the proof is
seldom, and at the centre of everything there may never have been anyone at
The role of two fiction houses is quite obvious, they are created to make
people hear something, something that they want to identify, but it is so faint
and distant that human beings are unable to make it out. Not quite simple
things, but much more difficult and complex matters. By creating their haunted
houses, both writers wanted to show that there was no logical explanation to certain
supernatural phenomena. In both cases haunted houses were main protagonists
that wanted to prevent people from some awful actions. The worst thing was that
they affected everyone, not only those who lived in these houses, but the
neighbours and other members of the society as well. Such was the notion of
Mullen and Jackson.
supernatural occurrences may or may not be directly connected to someone
special. In fact, neither the characters nor readers are quite sure of what
they experience in Haunting of Hill House and Tales of Horror
- but all are profoundly effected by them. For instance, in Tales of Horror
readers are really affected by the power of each sentence: "This house has
been Lived in, he said, speaking in a low tone but with great intensity, by an
extremely Beautiful but utterly evil woman. Yes, yes, I feel that too. This
week Workmen are taking the thing apart, stone by stone. Oh this? Just. a
little something I found in the ruins. Don't bring it into the house!"
(Mullen, p. 12). This description doesn't seem very logic, but it has the power
to stir our feelings and emotions.
In summary, a real haunted house is a place that hides many secrets of
good and evil, of morality and crimes. Human beings are unable to understand
these phenomena because they don't want to accept things that frighten them,
they don't want to look at the core of these supernatural events. They start
with the basics, and as they grow older, they begin to focus more on the
details. And it is obvious that obsession with details to the exclusion of the
basics is a sure way to begin losing the true facts, the real understanding.
1. Jackson Shirley. The
Haunting of Hill House, Penguin, 1984.
2. Mullen Laura. The
Tales of Horror, Kelsey Street Press, 1999.